Debate of the Week: Is AI Creating the Next Boom or Exposing the Next Bubble?
This week’s defining debate centred on whether artificial intelligence is driving a durable productivity cycle or quietly amplifying fragility beneath the surface.
On one side, the case for acceleration continues to strengthen. Britain is backing frontier research with billion dollar funding rounds. Patent rules are being liberalised. Enterprise AI monetisation is proving real in software earnings. Infrastructure players are securing power, data and distribution. The rally in breadth across the S&P 500 suggests participation is widening rather than narrowing. In this framing, AI is embedding across industries and expanding margins faster than disruption can destroy them.
On the other side, stress signals are becoming harder to ignore. Private credit freezes echo earlier cycles. Software leverage looks vulnerable if refinancing windows tighten. AI threatens parts of cybersecurity, pharma economics and entry level cognitive work. Equity markets are repricing some information based industries before earnings estimates adjust. The debate is no longer about whether AI matters. It is about who controls the value chain and who gets disintermediated.
That tension defined the week.
Further Discussion Inside the Collective
Beyond the central AI debate, members focused on the structural shifts reshaping capital flows, sector leadership and policy risk.
Trade policy uncertainty moves into phase two
Following the Supreme Court ruling on tariffs, markets absorbed a softer but more complex protectionist regime. While headline risk declined, trade barriers remain embedded in policy. Investors are now pricing slower, narrower and more targeted interventions rather than sweeping shocks.
US exceptionalism quietly fades
Fund flow data shows the United States capturing a shrinking share of global equity inflows. The shift is not dramatic outflows but relative rotation, reinforcing a gradual broadening of leadership beyond US mega caps.
Private credit stress raises uncomfortable parallels
Freezes in private credit vehicles and weakness in listed alternative asset managers triggered comparisons with 2007 style early warning signals. The question is whether current stress remains isolated to leveraged pockets or evolves into a broader refinancing issue.
The K shaped economy accelerates
Premium travel, high end hospitality and ultra luxury pricing remain exceptionally strong, while mid market consumer names struggle. The divergence between the top and bottom half of the consumer continues to widen, reinforcing dispersion across sectors.
Real assets regain institutional favour
Industrial capacity, steel, logistics and uranium exposure attracted renewed interest. Structural themes such as carbon border mechanisms, domestic supply rebuilding and energy security continue to support asset heavy industries over capital light growth narratives.
AI disruption broadens into new industries
Healthcare, cybersecurity and finance all saw evidence that AI is moving from theory to application. Productivity gains may compress margins in some sectors while expanding them in others. The market is increasingly pricing both opportunity and threat simultaneously.
.svg)
