Florida everglades

A network of lakes, marshes and streams is suing Florida

What’s happening? A lawsuit has been filed on behalf of a network of lakes, marshes and streams in Florida in an attempt to stop a housing development that would destroy the waterways. The lawsuit, which is targeted at the state and a developer, was filed under a “rights of nature” law passed in November 2020. The law secures the rights of waterways to exist, flow, maintain healthy ecosystems and receive protection from pollution. The lawsuit also argues that the development would disrupt hydrology and violate the human right to clean water. The case is the first of its kind in the US. (The Guardian)

Why does this matter? In order for us to benefit from the valuable ecosystem services the natural world provides, it (obviously) needs to continue to exist.

In the case of marshes and wetlands, the services they provide range from improving water quality, storing floodwaters and recharging groundwater supplies, to providing a habitat for fish and other wildlife. Then, there is the intrinsic value of the ecosystem itself, existing independently of any human-constructed ideas about its worth.

Unfortunately, despite a variety of different preservation approaches, the natural world is in decline and biodiversity is disappearing. Only around 3% of the world’s land is ecologically intact and last year it emerged that none of the UN’s 10-year global biodiversity goals, set in 2010, have been met.

Rights for rivers – The Florida waterways and Everglades unfortunately won’t flow into a court, somehow develop sentience and the ability to speak and then legally represent themselves. Chuck O’Neal, president of Speak Up Wekiva, is doing so on their behalf. He said he hopes the court “reaches beyond current conventional thinking” to make a decision, and that the case represents the next step in the evolution of rights – beyond human beings.

Similar concepts exist elsewhere. In 2019, Bangladesh granted its rivers the equivalent legal status as humans. This means the country’s National River Conservation Commission was given the power to take individuals harming rivers to court. This concept of “environmental personhood” gives environmental entities legal personalities to appear in court against development and property-based ownership. Ecuador became the first country to enshrine the legal rights of nature in its constitution in 2008, followed by Bolivia in 2001.

Natural capital – Fundamentally, the degradation of nature is in part due to our failure to account properly for its value in our economic thinking. There are moves to more properly address “natural capital” in economic assessments, with the UN recently adopting a framework that goes beyond GDP to do so. This is an approach recommended by the UK’s landmark Dasgupta review on biodiversity published earlier this year.

Other novel approaches are being explored to protect biodiversity. Conservation organisations recently bought a 950 sq km biodiversity hotspot in Belize to preserve it from deforestation. Meanwhile, research has indicated one way to prevent increasing deforestation in the Amazon is to restore property rights to local tribes in the region.

This article first appeared in our weekly newsletter, Sustt.

Read more articles

Sign up to Sustt

Share This Post

You might also like

Oil and gas

Billions of tonnes of carbon to be emitted by 20 nations’ proposed oil and gas projects by 2050: report

What’s happening? The top 20 global oil and gas producers are poised to release 173 billion tonnes of carbon emissions ...

Read more

Sam Robinson
September 19, 2023

Avatar photo

UNEP issues first draft of global treaty to cut plastic pollution

What’s happening? The UN Environment Programme (UNEP) has published its first draft of a global treaty to end plastic pollution by ...

Read more

Nicola Watts
September 14, 2023

Avatar photo
Iceberg in water

As the ice melts in the Arctic, concerns grow over its exploitation

What’s happening? As the Arctic's drifting sea ice steadily diminishes, the area becomes more vulnerable to fishing, shipping, mining, and pollution. ...

Read more

Dillon Creedon
September 8, 2023